From the Telegraph this morning: “My husband had to change polling booth yesterday morning, as the bit of string on the pencil was too short to allow his left-handed X to be written.”
Dr Gail Young
Any thoughts/comments?
Knocking elbows!
From Viv Smith
“I’m left handed, the daughter of a left hander. I was recently reminded of my experience in primary school aged 8 when a very annoying teacher placed me next to a right hander. I was on his right therefore we battled elbows everyday. When I complained she refused to let us swap sides and cure the problem. I wrote this poem about the event”
.
Write Left
Little Laura could only write
With her pen in her left hand, never her right.
Armed like this her words could flow,
Her stories were rich, her ideas would grow.
Her problem was being sat next to Ricky,
Everyone knew he was tough and quite tricky.
Just like his fists, Ricky wrote with his right,
Sprawled over the desk his left hand clenched tight.
He put pen to paper to reveal to his peers
His astonishing wealth of stupid ideas.
Laura sat hunched in a small bit of table
That Ricky had spared her, until she felt able
To move her left arm and free up her mind
From staring at Ricky’s humongous behind.
Laura spoke to the teacher, but poor Mrs Hyde
Was just grateful that Ricky remained occupied.
One day Little Laura sat down on the left.
Then Ricky arrived and looked vaguely bereft.
To have to shift over to the opposite side
Was confusing for Ricky and a matter of pride.
“Just try it” said Laura, “and I think you will see
It’ll work just as well for you as for me”.
Ricky said nothing sitting down with a groan
He took the new seat, fists flexed for a moan.
But when writing began he started to see
The girl had a point, his right arm felt free.
Laura sat upright, her left arm could move
And Ricky, for once, had nothing to prove.
Copyright Viv Smith
A great poem! Any thoughts or comments?
Knocking Elbows!
From Viv Smith
“I’m left handed, the daughter of a left hander. I was recently reminded of my experience in primary school aged 8 when a very annoying teacher placed me next to a right hander. I was on his right therefore we battled elbows everyday. When I complained she refused to let us swap sides and cure the problem. I wrote this poem about the event.”
Did anyone else go through this at school?
Meeting at the Department of Education Wednesday 12th Feb 2019
Delighted to be able to make our presentation (along with Sue Smits of Morrells Handwriting, Worcester) at the Department of Education on Wednesday 12th February, with Robin Walker MP for Worcester in attendance.
It was positively received and we look forward to some progress in the near future!
Education system – Apathetic at best, discriminatory at worst!
The parents of the child with the pencil grip as shown drives over 150 miles to get help! The mother writes:
“My daughter attends primary school in Wanstead, London, and I sadly understand that her case is not untypical. She has never had any support with writing at school, and has now, in year 6, developed a problem with her grip. We spoke to the school and her class teacher said that she knew nothing about left handedness, and that my daughter had neat handwriting and she should expect that it hurts to write as they write more in year 6. The teacher said it hurt her hand after marking books.
After a dismissal from the teacher after two minutes, we took matters into our own hand and visited a specialist in Worcestershire. He corrected Alice’s grip in 15 minutes.”
During repeated correspondence with ministers at The Department of Education, the following fallback has been used “The Teachers’ Standards require teachers to adapt their teaching to address the needs of all their pupils, whatever those needs may be”. If teachers are unable to identify the specific needs of the child, they are not going to take any action..
Hardly surprising that this teacher did nothing as “she knew nothing about left-handedness”. The teacher is not to blame – there is nothing in Initial Teacher Training on left-handedness nor in the Teacher Assessment Framework.
Is this fair on the child? Absolutley NOT! (And potentially over 1,000,000 left-handed children but the Dof E hasn’t got any idea how many left-handed children there are!)
Can this situation be easily sorted? It absolutely CAN! Simple training as part of ITT and CPD.
And it’s WIN for the child, WIN for the school and WIN for the country!
So, apathetic or discriminatory? Or both?
And that’s an ofsted outstanding school!!
Mum says ”
I went for a meeting with her teacher.
It ended after two minutes, as her teacher says: “She doesn’t know much about left handedness and would have to research it. It’s not a problem as the only reason …..s hand hurts writing essays is that they write more in year 6. Her hand hurts after doing lots of marking”
So they don’t know and don’t care.
Especially as …… is the only left hander in the class.
And that’s an ofsted outstanding school!!
It beggars belief that there is still such ignorance! Not that it is the teacher’s fault as it is not part of Initial Teacher Training and the National Curriculum only views it as “NON-statutory” in the handwriting section!
“We want every child to have the best possible start in life.”
This is a sentiment I entirely agree with; it goes without saying doesn’t it? This came via an email which linked to the Conservatives web site “Building a Britain fit for the future,” which states
“Schools & Skills
We want every child to have the best possible start in life.”
Now what would your understanding of the word “every” be? Does it mean a few, some, a lot or all? My understanding is that “every” means “all“.
But if the Dept of Education has no figures on a specific group of children, whether the specific needs of those children within that group has any impact on their academic achievement, where teachers are not trained in those specific needs as part of their initial teacher training, where their particular handwriting needs are NON -statutory (for everyone else it is a Statutory requirement!), you might reasonably come to the conclusion that the word “every” has a different meaning! Maybe it should read “the majority”?
In case you are wondering, it is the group of left-handed children in our Education system I am talking about.
The attached letter from Rt Hon Damian Hinds MP Secretary of State states that “The Teachers Standards require teachers to adapt their teaching to address the needs of all their pupils, whatever those needs might be”. Again a fine sentiment but, in my opinion, it makes a huge and completely unfounded assumption; that is that teachers have been trained to help left-handed children, that they are aware of what to look out for and trained to act appropriately.
If that were the case, why were we encouraged by Nick Gibb MP to have input into the new Teacher Training Curriculum and why do schools ask me to run training courses for their staff? If all was fine and dandy in the classrooms for left-handed children, I wouldn’t need to be writing this!
A few techniques later and she has improved immensely!
“I visited this amazing shop with 2 of my children today. My daughter is left handed and has always struggled with her handwriting. 10 minutes in the store with the amazing owner and a few techniques later and she has improved immensely! I am over the moon and completely gob smacked by the kindness and generosity of the gent in this store! We bought a few left handed bits and pieces and she has been writing since we got home this afternoon! Plus the lovely lady in the shop played with my 2 year old so I could spend some time with Phoebe!!
Absolutely amazing service and incredible toys and left handed stock!!!
Thank you so much to all that helped us today! I hope you know how much confidence you gave my daughter!”
Such kind words but it shows how a small amount of appropriate help can make such a positive difference! This is why helping left-handed children should be part of Initial Teacher Training and CPD in all our Primary Schools.
Would you be happy with this?
This is a hypothetical question: “Would you be happy with this?”
I would like to think that no one who has any understanding of handwriting, be they parent, Early Years practitioner, teacher, SENCO, Head teacher, School Governor, education advisor, Teacher trainer, Education Minister and even Secretary of State for Education, would consider such a grip to be “good”!
It is blatantly obvious that such a grip would mean that the child’s hand would cover their writing as they go along and would smudge, making messy writing, messy hands, difficulty reading what they have written as well as lower marks than the content would necessarily merit.
If the child was trying to get their pen license, what are the chances of getting it?
I could go on! What I find frustrating is that it appears that no one in authority has the inclination to say “Let’s do something about this”. It’s not rocket science, time consuming or expensive to sort, and yet left-handed children are NOT being given appropriate help.
When the new Initial Teacher Training curriculum was being put together, we had some input into that. However, when published, there was not a word on left-handed children. Potentially over, 1,000,000 children and their needs are not being adequately met. If they were, children wouldn’t be coming into our shop for handwriting help!
Appropriate teacher training and guidance for the children will improve the educational outcomes. Win/Win all round; I reckon so.
This child is left handed and last year during school nursery the keyperson tried to get them to switch hands for writing.
Text taken from a Facebook conversation 6th July 2108
Looking for advice for a friend. My son had his friend over for dinner last night. After dinner between 5-5:30 we do homework. Both reception aged children. This kid excelled in the maths part of homework however when it came to writing I literally watched their confidence and body language deplete. Mum popped over this morning to say thank you for having them for tea yesterday. Happen to mention my observation. So we had a chat about it. Points of concern and I would just like your view points on as childcare practitioners:
- we always see this child in the morning they are very distressed that mum is leaving. They have to lock the class room door to stop them from running out and away because mum has gone
- this child is left handed and last year during school nursery the keyperson tried to get them to switch hands for writing.
- school have not provided child with left handed scissors so struggled to cut “straight lines” when request and gets upset when pulled up on it.
- child holds pencil as standard left handed child however when writes will start from the bottom of the letter for example “g” and “e” they will start with the tail moving towards the centre. School have rhymes and encourage they “take off the lid and scoop it out” however they find it hurts their hands to stretch that way starting from the middle.
- child has a speech impedimant and has failed their reception hearing test. Referral to GP has been made but often feels like people are not listening to them when they raise their own points of concern. When it could be a mixture of a) not understanding in the first place because of their speech impediment and b) seem to be fed up with trying to teach them the “proper” way to write and just ignore them when they say “but it hurts to do it that way”
- when mum has spoken to the lead eyfs leader they have said “there is a curriculum in place with the writing and rhymes and they have to learn to do it that way” – but their way clearly isn’t working for this one child. My own son is also left handed and has no issues with this programme but when they tried to get him to write right handed last year I jumped on them for it. To sum up he seems unhappy at school drop off I imagine because his needs are not being supported by the school.
I thought that making left-handed children write right-handed was a thing of the past but maybe not!!!